Keating snubs Man City: Where next for England’s rising goalkeeper?

Khiara Keating’s decision to walk away from Manchester City this summer has sent ripples through English football’s goalkeeper pipeline. The 21-year-old England international, a lifelong City fan and academy graduate, has turned down a new contract offer and now faces a pivotal choice: pursue regular first-team football elsewhere, or gamble on a longer-term project at the club she grew up supporting. With her current deal expiring in 2026 and limited game time at City last season, the door to a move is wide open—and several WSL clubs are already circling.

Why Keating’s exit from City is a calculated risk

Keating’s departure is not a rejection of ambition, but a response to the realities of competing for minutes in a squad stacked with talent. Last season, she started just four WSL games behind Japan international Ayaka Yamashita, despite City winning the league title and the Women’s FA Cup. The competition for the number one shirt is fierce, and with no guarantee of more starts next term, Keating’s decision to explore other options reflects a desire for guaranteed playing time rather than a vote of no confidence in the club. Her WSL Golden Glove award in 2023-24—aged 19 and the youngest ever recipient—proves her quality, but trophies alone do not satisfy a player seeking regular action.

Her England pathway has also hit turbulence. After making her senior debut at Manchester City’s Etihad Stadium in October 2024, Keating was omitted from the Euro 2025 squad and missed out on June’s World Cup qualifiers with a concussion. The competition for England’s goalkeeping spots is intensifying, with Mary Earps still the undisputed first choice. Regaining a place in Sarina Wiegman’s squad before next year’s tournament will require consistent club football, and a move away from City could provide that platform.

The clubs circling—and what they offer

Liverpool have emerged as the most credible suitor. Gareth Taylor, who oversaw Keating’s breakthrough season at City in 2023-24 and handed her a WSL debut, remains an admirer. His side is in urgent need of a goalkeeper after Jennifer Falk’s loan ended in May and permanent talks stalled. Taylor’s familiarity with Keating’s strengths—her command of her box, reflexes, and composure under pressure—could smooth a transition, but Liverpool’s defensive frailties last term raise questions about the immediate competitiveness of the project.

Other WSL clubs are monitoring the situation, though none have been publicly named. Keating’s reputation as one of England’s brightest young goalkeepers ensures interest, but her next destination will hinge on more than just ambition. A club with a clear pathway to silverware, or at least a stable environment where she can thrive, will hold the strongest appeal. The risk of joining a side battling relegation or mid-table mediocrity could undermine her England ambitions, making the choice as much about tactical fit as it is about ambition.

What this means for England’s goalkeeping future

Keating’s situation underscores a broader challenge for England’s goalkeeper pipeline: balancing development with the need for game time. With Earps nearing the end of her peak years and younger options like Lauren James and Hannah Hampton pushing for recognition, Keating’s career trajectory will be scrutinised closely. A move to a club where she can command a starting berth could fast-track her progress, but the wrong decision could stall her momentum at a critical juncture.

The timing of her exit also coincides with wider shifts in the WSL. Clubs are investing in infrastructure, with Manchester United overcoming a key hurdle in their bid to build a 100,000-seat stadium, signalling a new era of ambition in the women’s game. Yet for players like Keating, the immediate priority is minutes, not marquee projects. Her next move will reveal whether she prioritises legacy at City or seizes the chance to define her own path elsewhere.

One thing is certain: Keating’s decision has exposed the fragility of long-term planning in women’s football. Clubs often preach patience, but for a 21-year-old with England ambitions, the clock is ticking louder than ever.

Related coverage

Manchester United overcome key hurdle in bid to build new 100,000-seat stadium · England latest: Tuchel ‘demands high standards’, says Spence after viral training clip