Maresca’s Man City rebuild: how deep is the damage vs Guardiola?

Enzo Maresca’s first days at Manchester City have been bathed in the afterglow of Pep Guardiola’s decade-long reign, but the Italian’s real work begins now. The squad he inherits is a product of Guardiola’s meticulous construction: a blend of technical precision, tactical flexibility, and the kind of depth that made City the benchmark for consistency. Yet beneath the sheen of six Premier League titles and a Champions League crown lies a question Maresca must answer before the transfer window slams shut: which Guardiola-era pieces fit his vision, and which are expendable?

Squad depth vs. tactical identity

City’s current roster is undeniably deep, but depth alone won’t define Maresca’s early success. The opening fixtures—Bournemouth, Crystal Palace, Coventry—offer a sympathetic start, yet they also expose a squad still adjusting to life without Guardiola’s signature patterns. Rodri, who played nearly every minute of Spain’s World Cup triumph, is the most obvious fatigue risk, and his phased return will test Maresca’s rotation strategy. The Italian’s acknowledgment that he’s inheriting a “well-balanced squad with incredible talent” is accurate, but balance doesn’t always translate to immediate cohesion under a new system.

More pressing is the need to reconcile City’s transitional phase with the Premier League’s evolving landscape. Liverpool and Manchester United loom in September, and a stumble against either could derail early momentum. Maresca’s familiarity with the club—having served as an academy coach and Guardiola’s assistant during the 2022-23 treble campaign—gives him an edge, but his first real test will be whether he can imprint his own identity without dismantling the foundations.

The Haaland factor: legacy and leverage

Erling Haaland’s presence looms large over Maresca’s rebuild. The Norwegian’s 100th Premier League goal was immortalised in a commemorative ball, now a centrepiece of City’s auction of Guardiola’s office memorabilia—a symbolic passing of the torch. Haaland’s form at the World Cup, where he faced England in a high-profile quarter-final, underscored his status as a global marquee asset. Maresca must decide whether to build around Haaland as the focal point or diversify the attack to mitigate his occasional isolation.

Haaland’s World Cup showdown with Jude Bellingham, widely covered in the football press, highlighted the striker’s ability to dominate even in unfamiliar tactical setups. Yet City’s reliance on his physical presence risks stagnation if Maresca fails to integrate more fluid alternatives. The auction of Guardiola’s office items—including pitch pads with handwritten strategies—serves as a reminder of the tactical legacy Maresca must either preserve or reshape.

Rebuild or refine?

Maresca’s challenge is twofold: manage expectations while executing a rebuild that respects City’s recent dominance. The squad’s depth, built over years of Guardiola’s meticulous recruitment, provides cover for experimentation, but the Premier League’s relentless calendar demands ruthless efficiency. Rodri’s potential fatigue, for instance, could force Maresca to accelerate the development of younger midfielders or seek a direct replacement.

Tactically, Maresca must decide whether to double down on Guardiola’s positional play or introduce a more pragmatic approach. The opening fixtures offer breathing space, but the September clashes with Liverpool and United will reveal whether City’s new era can withstand pressure. The squad’s balance is undeniable, yet balance alone won’t secure trophies—only adaptation will.

City’s transfer window will be decisive. Maresca must identify which Guardiola-era players align with his philosophy and which are surplus to requirements. The depth that once defined City’s dominance could become a liability if it dilutes the team’s identity. As the auction of Guardiola’s office items suggests, the club is already looking to the future—Maresca’s next move must do the same.

Related coverage

Erling Haaland makes Jude Bellingham feelings clear after World Cup showdown · England vs Norway LIVE – World Cup quarter-final score updates as Harry Kane and Erling Haaland face off