Paraguay beat Germany on penalties to reach last 16 of World Cup 2026 –as it happened

Paraguay’s players will not soon forget the night they ended Germany’s World Cup ambitions. A composed penalty routine saw them eliminate the hosts 4-3 after a 1-1 draw in extra time, sealing a place in the last 16 and writing one of the tournament’s most unlikely chapters. Julian Nagelsmann’s side, already under pressure after a limp defeat to Ecuador, collapsed in the knockout phase for the first time in a penalty shoot-out at a World Cup. The defeat leaves Germany’s campaign in tatters and sends Paraguay into the next round with momentum few expected.

How Paraguay turned the screw

Paraguay began brightly, Antonio Enciso’s fourth-minute strike giving them the lead and exposing German nerves. Kai Havertz equalised midway through the second half, but Paraguay refused to yield. In stoppage time, Rodrigo Gomez restored their advantage, only for Antonio Rüdiger’s header to force extra time. The drama stretched deep into the 120th minute, when Niclas Füllkrug forced a save from Paraguay’s goalkeeper, but the Paraguayan wall held firm.

The shoot-out was clinical. Paraguay converted all four of their first attempts, while Germany faltered twice. Robin Gosens and Jamal Musiala scored, but Niclas Füllkrug and Antonio Rüdiger both saw their penalties saved. Jose Canale, who had defended resolutely throughout, stepped up to slot home the winner, sparking wild celebrations on the bench. The Paraguayan bench erupted as Canale’s kick flew past Manuel Neuer, sealing a historic victory.

Germany’s unravelling and what comes next

Germany’s exit marks the first time they have lost a World Cup penalty shoot-out, a stain on a campaign that began with such promise. Nagelsmann’s frustration was palpable after their final group-stage defeat to Ecuador, when he rejected the suggestion that his players lacked desire. “They didn’t want it more,” he insisted. “I cannot tell any of my players they didn’t give it their all.” Yet the numbers tell a different story: one win, one draw, and one defeat left them third in their group, and now they are heading home.

Paraguay, meanwhile, advance to face either England or Senegal in the Round of 16. Their disciplined defensive shape frustrated Germany’s midfield, while their direct counters repeatedly tested the hosts’ backline. The victory is a statement of intent from a nation more accustomed to narrow margins than knockout glory. Jose Canale, whose composure under pressure defined the night, will be the man Paraguayan fans remember.

Tactical clarity and individual brilliance

Paraguay’s gameplan was immaculate. They absorbed Germany’s early pressure, absorbed the setbacks of conceding an equaliser, and then relied on their composure in transition. Enciso’s opener exposed Germany’s vulnerability to quick counters, while Gomez’s late strike demonstrated their willingness to exploit defensive lapses. In defence, Jose Canale marshalled the backline with rare authority, while Rodrigo Gomez’s movement stretched Germany’s defence at every turn.

Germany, by contrast, struggled to impose their rhythm. Havertz’s equaliser was a rare moment of individual quality, but their midfield was overrun at times, and their finishing in the shoot-out betrayed their desperation. The defeat is a sobering reminder that possession alone does not guarantee progress, and that penalties remain football’s most brutal arbiter.

As Paraguay celebrate, and Germany reflect on a tournament that promised so much but delivered so little, one truth is clear: knockout football rewards the ruthless, and on this night, Paraguay were ruthless enough.