Schlotterbeck World Cup exit leaves Germany scrambling for fix

Germany’s World Cup campaign has been thrown into fresh uncertainty after Nico Schlotterbeck’s ankle ligament injury ruled him out of the tournament, leaving Thomas Nagelsmann scrambling to shore up a defence that had already survived a scare against Ivory Coast.

The blow that changes Germany’s tournament

Schlotterbeck’s exit is a hammer blow. The 26-year-old Borussia Dortmund defender, who had played every minute of Germany’s opening 7-1 win over Curaçao, limped off with a medial collateral ligament tear in his left ankle during the 2-1 victory over Ivory Coast. His half-time replacement, Antonio Rüdiger, stepped in but the damage was done: Schlotterbeck will miss the rest of the tournament and faces several months on the sidelines. With squad replacements unavailable mid-tournament, Nagelsmann must now navigate the knockout stages without a player he had described as “outstanding,” particularly for his build-up play.

Nagelsmann’s public reaction was measured but revealing. “Schlotti will be greatly missed on the pitch,” he said. “It could have been his World Cup.” The coach also praised Schlotterbeck’s resilience, noting the defender’s positive attitude even as he remains with the squad in the USA. That presence, Nagelsmann suggested, is valuable off the pitch as well as on. Yet the loss of a player who had already featured in every minute of Germany’s campaign leaves a void that cannot be filled by sentiment.

Who steps into the breach?

Germany’s remaining centre-back options read like a list of stopgaps rather than guarantees. Jonathan Tah, Rüdiger, Waldemar Anton and Newcastle’s Malick Thiaw are the names now tasked with shoring up the backline. None of them, individually, commands the same aura as Schlotterbeck, whose left-footed comfort on the ball and progressive passing had made him a linchpin in Nagelsmann’s system. The coach insists the group is “very well positioned,” but the evidence is thin: Rüdiger, at 35, is a veteran of tournament football, while Tah and Thiaw have featured sporadically in recent months. Anton, the uncapped Hannover defender, adds depth but little proven pedigree at this level.

This is not the first time Germany have faced defensive upheaval at a major tournament. Tuchel’s centre-back dilemma after Croatia concerns in 2022 showed how quickly form and fitness can destabilise even the most settled backlines. Nagelsmann’s challenge now is to avoid a repeat, especially after Deniz Undav’s dramatic late winner against Ivory Coast kept Germany’s campaign alive. That 94th-minute strike, which sealed their place in the last 16 for the first time in 12 years, masked the frailties that Schlotterbeck’s absence will now expose.

The knockout-stage test

Germany’s route to the latter stages has been anything but smooth. A 7-1 demolition of Curaçao offered little insight into their true strength, while the fightback against Ivory Coast—coming from behind after Franck Kessié’s opener—revealed both resilience and fragility. Schlotterbeck’s injury means Nagelsmann must now gamble on a reshuffled defence against Ecuador, knowing that a single lapse could end their campaign prematurely. The Ecuadorians, unbeaten in their last five matches, will not offer the same generosity as Curaçao.

Nagelsmann’s tactical flexibility will be tested. If he opts for a back three, Rüdiger and Tah could form a partnership, with Thiaw or Anton providing cover. Alternatively, a back four might demand more from the full-backs, who will need to cover the ground Schlotterbeck’s absence creates. The coach’s ability to instil confidence in a unit that has rarely looked settled will be as crucial as any tactical tweak.

Schlotterbeck’s injury also raises questions beyond the pitch. His contract extension with Dortmund, signed in April until 2031, had suggested long-term faith in his abilities. Now, Germany must confront the possibility that their brightest defensive talent of this generation may never feature at a World Cup. That realisation will weigh heavily as Nagelsmann plots a path through the knockout rounds.

What comes next?

Germany’s World Cup story was always going to be judged on results, not sentiment. Schlotterbeck’s exit forces a recalibration. The coach’s public optimism about his remaining options is understandable, but the margin for error has narrowed. One mistake, one misplaced pass, one hesitation in transition—any of these could now prove decisive. Ecuador await, and they will not forgive Germany’s defensive lapses.

Nagelsmann’s task is clear: find a way to make the sum of Tah, Rüdiger, Anton and Thiaw greater than its parts. It is a challenge that demands more than just reshuffling personnel; it requires a reimagining of how Germany defend under pressure. Schlotterbeck’s absence is not just a loss of a player, but a loss of a system’s rhythm. The question now is whether Germany can rediscover that rhythm in time—or whether their World Cup will unravel before it truly begins.