Scotland’s McGinn ends 28-year World Cup wait with winner

John McGinn’s right foot ended Scotland’s 28-year World Cup drought in Boston on Tuesday night. The Aston Villa captain, then aged 31 years and 238 days, became the oldest Scottish scorer at a men’s World Cup when he struck after a nervy start to secure a 1-0 victory over Haiti and keep Steve Clarke’s side alive in Group C. Yet the manner of the win—earned amid defensive lapses and a VAR controversy elsewhere—left more questions than answers about Scotland’s readiness for the challenges ahead.

McGinn’s moment arrives after years of waiting

McGinn’s goal arrived in the 49th minute, but the moment had been building since Scotland last played at a men’s World Cup in 1998. His strike surpassed Kenny Dalglish’s 42-year-old benchmark for Scotland’s oldest World Cup scorer. The difference this time was not just the goal, but the context. Scotland had weathered early pressure from Haiti, with Che Adams’s effort saved before McGinn pounced on the rebound. The relief for the Tartan Army was palpable—after 28 years, the wait was over.

McGinn’s composure under pressure—both in possession and in the tackle—offered a glimpse of the man who has dragged Scotland to this stage. His leadership was evident in the way Scotland regrouped after Haiti’s lively opening exchanges, where Isidor’s clumsy challenge gifted Scotland an early free kick and Shankland nearly gifted the ball away in midfield. The Aston Villa midfielder’s ability to read the game and recycle possession under pressure allowed Scotland to weather the storm and eventually take control.

Defensive frailties nearly derail the party

Yet for all the celebration, the defensive frailties that have dogged Scotland in recent years resurfaced. Haiti, ranked among the lowest seeds in the tournament, carved out clear chances in the opening exchanges, with Deedson forcing a save from an unmarked goalkeeper. The early exchanges were chaotic, with Shankland’s loose touch nearly gifting Haiti their first meaningful attack. Even after McGinn’s goal, Scotland remained vulnerable, relying on McTominay’s aerial presence and Robertson’s experience to steady the ship.

The concerns were not just tactical. The tournament’s wider issues—empty seats in stadiums amid exorbitant ticket prices—underscored the disconnect between FIFA’s commercial ambitions and the reality for fans. While Scotland’s players battled on the pitch, off it the spectacle felt diminished, a reminder that even historic wins can’t mask the broader dysfunction of a tournament still finding its footing.

The road ahead: nerves, VAR, and Morocco

With Morocco and Brazil still to come, Scotland’s path to the knockout stages remains precarious. A draw against Morocco in their next match would leave them reliant on results elsewhere, while a loss to Brazil could end their campaign before it truly begins. McGinn’s goal bought Clarke time, but the defensive lapses that nearly cost them against Haiti cannot be ignored. The question now is whether this Scotland side—built on grit and McGinn’s leadership—can tighten up when it matters most.

For now, the Tartan Army can celebrate. McGinn’s strike has given them something to sing about, a rare bright spot in a tournament already marred by controversy. But as the VAR failures in Qatar’s draw with Switzerland proved, football’s margins are razor-thin. Scotland’s next two games will demand more than just spirit—they will require precision.