Scotland’s new head coach hunt: who will revive Tartan Army’s fortunes?

Scotland’s search for a new head coach is entering its final phase, with the Scottish FA expected to name a successor to Steve Clarke within two weeks. The appointment will come less than three months after Clarke’s resignation, which followed Scotland’s group-stage exit at the World Cup this summer. The new manager will inherit a squad preparing for a Nations League campaign that begins away to Slovenia on 26 September, a fixture that now carries added significance as the first test of a fresh era.

Who is on the shortlist?

Craig Mulholland, the SFA’s chief football officer since May, has overseen a wide-ranging search that has included candidates from the UK and abroad. Interviews have been completed, and the process is now focused on finalising a preferred candidate. The identity of the shortlisted individuals has not been disclosed, and it remains unclear whether the next head coach will be Scottish or foreign. Steven Naismith, Clarke’s former assistant, has indicated he expects to remain in the national team set-up under the new regime, suggesting continuity may be prioritised in the staffing structure.

The urgency of the appointment reflects the broader context of Scotland’s World Cup 2026 ambitions. With the tournament qualifiers approaching, the SFA cannot afford prolonged uncertainty. The Nations League fixtures against Slovenia, Denmark, and Kazakhstan in late September will provide an early gauge of whether the new coach can steady the ship before the more demanding road to the World Cup resumes.

What does this mean for the Tartan Army?

Clarke’s seven-year tenure ended abruptly after Scotland’s World Cup exit, a setback that underscored the challenges of competing consistently at international level. The new coach will inherit a squad that has shown flashes of promise but lacks the consistency to progress beyond the group stage in major tournaments. The Nations League offers a chance to rebuild momentum, but the road to the 2026 World Cup will demand more than isolated performances.

The timing of the appointment aligns with a pivotal moment in Scotland’s football development. The SFA’s willingness to look beyond domestic candidates signals a desire for fresh ideas, whether through tactical innovation or man-management. The next head coach will face the dual task of restoring belief among supporters and delivering results that justify the investment in the role.

The tactical reset ahead

The departure of Clarke, who had signed a four-year contract in May, leaves a void that extends beyond personnel. His structured approach provided a framework that the new coach may choose to refine or overhaul entirely. The Nations League fixtures will offer the first glimpse of the new regime’s philosophy, whether it leans towards a pragmatic setup or a more progressive style.

Scotland’s recent struggles in major tournaments have often been attributed to defensive fragility and an inability to break down stubborn opponents. The next head coach will need to address these issues swiftly, particularly with World Cup 2026 qualifiers looming. The squad’s depth and tactical flexibility will be tested early, making the September fixtures a critical proving ground for the new leadership.

The SFA’s decision will shape not just the immediate future but the long-term trajectory of Scottish football. With the World Cup 2026 qualifiers on the horizon, there is little margin for error. The new head coach must strike a balance between short-term progress and sustainable development, ensuring that the Tartan Army’s ambitions are built on solid foundations.

As the countdown to the Slovenia match begins, the pressure on the SFA to get this appointment right has never been greater. The next two weeks will determine whether Scotland can turn a page and begin writing a new chapter—or whether the cycle of underachievement will continue.

Related coverage

World Cup 2026: England to face DRC, Clarke quits Scotland, South Korea president blasts team – live · World Cup LIVE: Scotland on the brink after new blow overnight as Steve Clarke storms off