Why England’s backline remains Tuchel’s biggest conundrum

England’s World Cup campaign has already delivered more drama than expected, but not necessarily the kind Thomas Tuchel wanted. After a nervy opening draw against Croatia, the Three Lions were again stifled creatively against Ghana, their second-game curse striking in perhaps its most frustrating form. Yet the real concern for Tuchel may not be England’s attack, but the defensive fragility that has surfaced in patches against modest opposition. The underlying issues are now impossible to ignore, particularly when viewed against the backdrop of a tournament where defensive solidity has historically decided World Cup finals.

England’s defensive tightrope

Across their first two matches, England have conceded just 0.87 expected goals (xG) according to Opta data, and faced only one shot on target against Ghana. Yet the underlying issues remain hard to ignore. Against Croatia, they were rattled for 45 minutes before a half-time intervention steadied the ship. Against Ghana, a glaring refereeing error—Ezri Konsa’s reckless challenge on Prince Adu, ignored by officials—could have cost them dearly. Ghana’s manager Carlos Queiroz didn’t mince words, questioning whether VAR was operational at the time. These are not the performances of a team that conceded zero goals during qualifying. They are the performances of a side still searching for cohesion at the back, particularly with Reece James potentially ruled out for the tournament through injury. The right-back’s absence leaves a significant void, one that Tuchel must address before the knockout stages.

The knockout blueprint

History suggests England’s defensive frailties could prove costly. Since the 1998 World Cup expansion, five of the seven winners have kept five clean sheets in the finals. Spain’s 2010 triumph, for instance, was built on four 1-0 knockout wins, conceding just one goal in the process. England, by contrast, have already shown they can be vulnerable even against sides not expected to trouble them. The contrast between qualifying and the group stage is stark: a team that looked impregnable in qualifying now appears shaky against opponents who lack the technical quality of traditional heavyweights. If this pattern continues, Tuchel’s men may struggle when the competition intensifies.

Tuchel’s tactical tightrope

England’s midfield has largely controlled games, but the defensive structure has repeatedly shown cracks. Against Ghana, the backline was exposed in transition, with Konsa’s error nearly decisive. Tuchel’s half-time adjustments have so far papered over the cracks, but the margin for error in the knockout stages will be razor-thin. The manager’s challenge is clear: shore up the defence without stifling the creativity that has driven England forward. The balance between aggression and caution has rarely looked so precarious, especially with James’ absence forcing a reshuffle in the right-back slot.

With tougher tests looming, Tuchel’s biggest conundrum is no longer whether England can score, but whether they can stop conceding. The signs so far are not reassuring, and the clock is ticking before the knockout stages demand a fully coherent defensive unit.

Group L guide | England’s routes to World Cup final
World Cup fixtures day-by-day | World Cup kits

Follow the World Cup in the Sky Sports app